Pennant Club strategy: build a roster for 162 games
Learn roster coverage, pitcher roles, player availability, and how to read Pennant Club's fictional season projection.
Draft for a full season
A 162-game roster has to do more than collect famous names. Pennant Club asks you to roll an MLB team, look at that team's best available players, and assign one player to an open role. The lineup has nine slots, including a designated hitter, and the pitching staff has one starter, two relievers, and a closer. A player can be selected only once, while flexible players can cover an open role that fits their eligibility.
Because teams roll at random and a player's strongest listed position may already be filled, keep an eye on the complete set of eligible choices. A versatile player can solve a roster gap. A higher raw rating can be less useful when the player duplicates a strength you already have or weakens the only available coverage for a tougher slot.
Balance the lineup and staff
The game evaluates both batting and pitching, so one side cannot carry a poor fit everywhere else. Catcher, the infield, outfield, and designated hitter each represent a different roster need. Pitching roles use a starter, two middle or setup relievers, and a closer; the interface labels those staff roles separately so the four picks form one usable staff.
When you choose, compare the player's game rating with the quality of the remaining open slots. Filling the only eligible catcher or shortstop may be more valuable than adding another star at a position where you already have strong coverage. The roster panel lets you review who is locked and which needs remain before the next team roll.
What the 162-game result means
The final screen converts the finished roster into a fictional record over a 162-game season. The team rating reflects the roster's game ratings, the balance between offense and pitching, and the way selected players fit the roster. The result is meant to compare draft builds and create a satisfying season finish.
It is not a real MLB forecast, betting estimate, or validated projection model. The game uses a hand-designed scale and roster-fit adjustments, then maps that score into a record range for play. Real team outcomes depend on injuries, playing time, park, defense, schedule, transactions, and many other factors that this small game does not simulate.
My Player and cross-era ratings
My Player starts with a position choice and a random six, seven, or eight-skill build. At each skill, a team roll chooses a current MLB club 75% of the time or an all-time team-and-decade cohort 25% of the time. You then choose one unused eligible player from the available candidates. For shortstop builds, the shortlist contains only players listed at shortstop. Current teams, historical cohorts, and selected players do not repeat.
Current player ratings use individual MLB The Show 26 attributes republished by The Show Ratings for matched cards across its public 40-man rosters, including players outside the Top 100. The saved snapshot has detailed attributes for 897 of 1,102 matched players. Missing skills use distinct estimates from 2026 MLB Stats API rates and position-specific fielding results; published OVR is the last fallback. Nineteen active players have no exact matched Show card and use season-stat estimates. All-time ratings are editorial career-strength profiles normalized to a shared 40–99 game scale. Neither historical values nor resulting player cards represent official MLB or MLB The Show scouting grades.
Data and limitations
Pennant Club's team and player pool is stored as a versioned local data snapshot so its game rules can be updated independently of the interface. The MLB data service and public rosters can change after a snapshot is prepared. Active status, team assignment, positions, and player availability may therefore differ from today's official roster or from an in-season transaction.
The source snapshot supplies player identities, team links, positions, and selected performance context; the game adds its own simplified ratings and role rules. It does not reproduce MLB logos, operate an official fantasy league, or imply endorsement by MLB or any player. Use the game's data note for the snapshot date and the named source when available.
Save, review, and start again
Your current draft is saved in this browser so you can return to it. The roster panel remains available while you make picks, and the result screen includes a review of the finished lineup and staff. Restarting clears the run and begins a fresh set of rolls. A separate browser or device has a separate save, and clearing browser data erases it.